Arkansas or Illinois? How to pick 8 vs. 9 matchup in 2023 March Madness bracket

Arkansas or Illinois? How to pick 8 vs. 9 matchup in 2023 March Madness bracket

When it’s time to make your March Madness selections, the toughest decisions come down to the 8-9 matchup. This year’s meeting between Arkansas and Illinois is no exception.

In what should be one of the most competitive games of the first round, the Razorbacks and Fighting Illini are two evenly matched teams.

Arkansas began the year ranked as high as 10th, while Illinois came in at 23rd. Neither team was ranked in the top 25 at season’s end, but both schools have plenty of talent to make noise in the NCAA Tournament.

Live NCAA bracket | TV schedule | Printable PDF

The Razorbacks are led by two NBA prospects, Anthony Black and Nick Smith Jr. The Fighting Illini are powered by two transfers, Terrence Shannon Jr. and Matthew Mayer.

Which team will prevail and advance to a likely matchup against No. 1 seed Kansas? The Sporting News takes a deeper look at the matchup.

Arkansas vs. Illinois odds

Arkansas vs. Illinois will tip on the first day of the Round of 64, Thursday, March 16. The Razorbacks have opened as slight favorites, according to odds from BetMGM. Below, you can find odds and details about the first-round matchup, including its time, date and TV channel.

  • Odds: Arkansas -2.5
  • Date: Thursday, March 16
  • Time: 4:30 p.m. ET
  • TV: TBS
  • Arena: Wells Fargo Arena, Des Moines, Iowa

MORE: Watch March Madness games with Sling TV

Arkansas (20-13, 8-9 SEC)

The Razorbacks were projected to be one of the best teams in the country with a loaded freshman recruiting class. Then the injury bug hit.

NBA prospect Nick Smith Jr. missed the start of the season — and multiple games throughout the year — with a nagging knee injury. Sophomore standout Trevon Brazile went down with a season-ending torn ACL. As a result, Arkansas was forced to adjust.

That allowed another NBA prospect to emerge, with freshman guard Anthony Black looking like a projected top-10 pick in 2023. The Razorbacks had their moments where they looked like the team they were expected to be, but continuity has not been on their side.

With Smith shaking off the rust this late in the season, Arkansas could be a dangerous team in the tournament.

  • NET ranking: 21
  • KenPom ranking: 20
  • Quad 1 record: 4-10
  • Quad 2 record: 4-2
  • Quad 3 record: 10-1
  • Quad 4 record: 2-0
  • Offensive efficiency ranking: 51
  • Defensive efficiency ranking: 16

Key players

Anthony Black, G, Fr. (6-7, 198): 12.8 ppg, 5.1 rpg, 4.2 apg, 2.0 spg

Nick Smith Jr., G, Fr. (6-5, 185): 14.0 ppg, 2.0 apg, 1.8 rpg, 0.9 spg

Ricky Council IV, G, Jr. (6-6, 205): 15.9 ppg, 3.4 rpg, 2.3 apg, 1.2 spg

Makhi Mitchell, F, Sr. (6-9, 230): 7.1 ppg, 5.5 rpg, 1.4 bpg, 1.2 apg

Jordan Walsh, F, Fr. (6-7, 205): 7.2 ppg, 4.1 rpg, 1.0 apg, 1.0 spg

Illinois (20-12, 11-9 Big Ten)

It was never going to be easy for Illinois to replace Kofi Cockburn, one of the greatest players in school history. With other key players graduating or transferring, this year’s Fighting Illini team is drastically different from the one that lost in the second round of last year’s tournament.

Now led by transfer portal acquisitions Terrence Shannon Jr. and Matthew Mayer, Illinois will try to make an unexpected March Madness run.

Shannon, a Texas Tech transfer, has excelled under head coach Brad Underwood, averaging 17.1 points per game. Mayer, a Baylor transfer and 2022 national champion, picked up right where he left off by averaging 12.8 points per game.

Can Illinois advance out of the first round of the NCAA Tournament for the third consecutive year?

  • NET ranking: 34
  • KenPom ranking: 33
  • Quad 1 record: 2-11
  • Quad 2 record: 7-1
  • Quad 3 record: 4-0
  • Quad 4 record: 7-0
  • Offensive efficiency ranking: 58
  • Defensive efficiency ranking: 32

Key players

Terrence Shannon Jr., G, Sr. (6-6, 210): 17.1 ppg, 4.7 rpg, 2.9 apg, 1.3 spg

Coleman Hawkins, F,  Jr. (6-10, 200): 9.9 ppg, 6.3 rpg, 3.0 apg, 1.2 bpg, 1.0 spg

Matthew Mayer, G, Sr. (6-9, 225): 12.8 ppg, 5.5 rpg, 1.3 bpg, 1.2 apg

Jayden Epps, G, Fr. (6-2, 190): 9.7 ppg, 1.9 rpg, 1.5 apg

Dain Dainja, F, Soph. (6-9, 270): 9.7 ppg, 5.5 rpg, 1.2 bpg

Arkansas vs. Illinois prediction

Arkansas is the pick here. The Razorbacks are just as good as the Fighting Illini on defense and it’s questionable whether Illinois can keep up with Arkansas on offense.

Even though their offensive efficiency ranking is very close — Arkansas at 51 and Illinois at 58 — the Razorbacks are a different team with a (relatively) healthy Smith.

Smith was once projected to be a top-five pick in the NBA Draft before a knee injury forced him to miss all but 12 games this season. He finally looked like himself over the last few weeks of conference play, going for 24 or more points in four of his last five games.

Shannon — a first-team All-Big Ten selection — will likely draw that matchup and he’ll have to be at his best to slow down the future pro. Will he be able to maintain that intensity on defense while also leading Illinois’ offense?

The answer to that question will likely be one of the keys to the game.

History of 8 vs. 9 matchups in NCAA Tournament

The 8-9 matchup is historically one of the biggest “coin flip” selections of the NCAA Tournament. Eight-seeds have a slight advantage over 9-seeds with a 76-72 record all time. Last year, however, only one 8-seed won its first-round matchup against the 9-seed.

Below is the recent history of 9-seeds upsetting 8-seeds in the first round of the NCAA Tournament.

Year Result
2022 Memphis 64, Boise State 53
2022 TCU 69, Seton Hall 42
2022 Creighton 72, San Diego State 69
2021 Wisconsin 85, UNC 62
2019 UCF 73, VCU 58
2019 Baylor 78, Syracuse 69
2019 Oklahoma 95, Ole Miss 72
2019 Washington 78, Utah State 61
2018 Alabama 86, Virginia Tech 83
2018 Kansas State 69, Creighton 59
2018 Florida State 67, Missouri 54
2017 Michigan State 78, Miami 58
2016 Butler 71, Texas Tech 61
2016 Providence 70, USC 69
2016 UConn 74, Colorado 67
2014 Pittsburgh 77, Colorado 48
2013 Temple 76, NC State 72
2013 Wichita State 73, Pittsburgh 55
2012 Saint Louis 61, Memphis 54
2011 Illinois 73, UNLV 62
2010 Wake Forest 81, Texas 80
2010 Northern Iowa 69, UNLV 66
2009 Siena 74, Ohio State 72
2009 Texas A&M 79, BYU 66